Michael Arace commentary: Nash’s situation stirs memories of Thornton deal

Most-recent members

Sign up for The Blue Zone

  • Puck Rakers

     A blog about the Blue Jackets and the NHL

    One Signed, Two Set Free

    The Blue Jackets have agreed to terms with defenseman Austin Madaisky on a three-year, entry-level contract, and the official deal should be announced shortly. Madaisky was a fifth-round pick (No. 124 overall) in the 2010 NHL entry draft.

    Two other picks - right winger Petr Straka (2nd round, No. 55) and defenseman Brandon Archibald (4th round, No. 94) - have been informed by the Blue Jackets that they won't be signed, sending them back in the pool of draftable players for next month's draft in Pittsburgh.

    Of those two, Straka is the mild surprise.

    He had 28-36-64 in 62 games with Rimouski (QMJHL) during his draft year, but tailed off badly the last two seasons. In 2010-11, he had 10-15-25 in 41 games. This season, he had 18-19-37 in 54 games. That's fewer points the last two seasons -- 62 in 95 games -- than he scored as a 17-year-old.

    However, Straka made a pretty good last-best argument for a deal with his performance in the QMJHL playoffs. He had 10-12-22 in 21 games, becoming a point-a-game player once again. The bet here is that he gets drafted his June, but certainly on Saturday (2nd through 7th rounds) and probably later in the day.

    The Blue Jackets acquired the pick used on Straka with the 2010 trade deadline deal that sent winger Raffi Torres to Buffalo.

    Madaisky, meanwhile, blossomed this season in his fourth year of juniors, the last three spent with Kamloops (WHL). He had 13 goals, 37 assists, 50 points and a plus-20 rating, all career highs. He also had 87 penalty minutes. He could play a fifth year of junior next season, or begin his pro career, likely with AHL Springfield.

    Blue Jackets GM Scott Howson and the hockey operations department face one last difficult decision as it pertains to the 2010 draft class. Goaltender Mathieu Corbeil remains unsigned, and the Jackets still aren't sure if they want to keep him in the fold.

    "We'll evaluate him in the Memorial Cup and make a decision," Howson said. "Not sure right now."

    Corbeil is 50-11-2 in the last two seasons with Saint John of the QMJHL, which won the Memorial Cup last season and is a favorite to repeat. Corbeil, named the QMJHL's goalie of the year, is 16-0-1 in this year's playoffs, with a 2.18 goals-against average and .917 save percentage.

    Those numbers will cause many readers to scratch their temples and wonder: "How could they possibly not want this guy?" What the Blue Jackets are trying to determine is if Corbeil is a product of a powerhouse hockey club or a goaltender with legitimiate NHL potential. These are the questions that keep scouts up late at night.

    Two weeks ago, the Blue Jackets seemed to be leaning away from signing Corbeil. These days it seems to be leaning back the other direction, though no decision has been made.

    -- Aaron Portzline

    aportzline@dispatch.com

    twitter: @aportzline

By Michael Arace

The Columbus Dispatch Wednesday February 22, 2012 2:29 PM

The deal came without warning, and it rocked the NHL: On Nov. 30, 2005, the Boston Bruins traded “Jumbo” Joe Thornton to the San Jose Sharks for defenseman Brad Stuart, speedy forward Marco Sturm and third-line center Wayne Primeau.

At the time, the Bruins were reeling. Their Calder Trophy-winning goaltender, Andrew Raycroft, had lost his form, and the team was losing apace. Thornton, despite leading the team in scoring (33 points in 24 games), was taking heat. Sound familiar?

Thornton was a 26-year-old captain then. Some thought he was too young and immature to bear the burden of the “C.” Some wondered where his power game had gone and why he no longer spent much time in front of the net. His play was described as disengaged, lackluster and indifferent.

Mike O’Connell, the Bruins’ general manager at the time, decided he no longer wanted to wait for Thornton to fulfill the lofty expectations that were placed on him back in 1997, when he was the No. 1 overall pick in the draft. O’Connell shipped off his superstar for three lesser players in an effort to plug holes and change the culture. O’Connell was fired four months later.

There are numerous differences between the Thornton situation in Boston 61/2 years ago and the current Rick Nash situation in Columbus.

“They’re not at all alike,” Thornton said yesterday morning.

Thornton and the Sharks were in town to play the Blue Jackets, and the game did not follow form. R.J. Umberger, who might be on the trading block, had a Gordie Howe hat trick; Jeff Carter, who is definitely on the block, had two goals; and Nash, who is famously on the block, added a highlight-reel goal. It all happened in the first period.

The Jackets won 6-3, and there were eight scouts in the press gallery.

Earlier, Thornton was asked about whether Nash’s situation gave him flashbacks to 2005. Thornton was not exactly warm to the subject, but he was gracious enough. He did not allow for any parallels, but there are a few, nonetheless.

Nash is 27 years old, huge, and in his prime. He is a former No. 1 overall pick and is among the elite power forwards in the NHL. The league was turned on its ear when word leaked that he is available to the right team, at the right price.

Thornton and Nash are friends. They scored at will as linemates in Davos, Switzerland, during the 2004-05 NHL lockout. They were key parts of the Canadian national team that won gold at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics.

Thornton was asked what his first thought was when he heard of Nash’s availability. Thornton just smiled. Not going there. He was asked whether he ever entertained the idea of having Nash, once again, on his left. He smiled again, and dodged.

“You’re just so focused on what you’re doing day to day,” he said. “I really don’t pay attention to what’s going on with other teams.”

Asked if he has spoken with Nash lately, Thornton smiled again. It has been suggested that Thornton might be doing some recruiting. Not going there, either.

San Jose has been mentioned as a possible place of landing for Nash, for two reasons: The Sharks, for all of their size and talent, have not been able to push through to the last round of the playoffs; and, of course, there is the Thornton-Nash connection.

The Jackets must be asking for a huge ransom — one much larger than what the Bruins got for Thornton. A steep price plus Nash’s large contract make the Sharks an unlikely trade partner. Boston might be a better fit, or the New York Rangers, or the Los Angeles Kings.

It might be that nothing gets done before the trade deadline. Perhaps a deal will have to wait until the summer, when teams have more flexibility. There is an off chance that Nash will stay right where he is, but if he moves, Thornton’s name will come up by way of a blockbuster comparison.

The Bruins, under GM Peter Chiarelli, ultimately won the Stanley Cup. It happened last summer, in spite of the Thornton deal rather than because of it.

Michael Arace is a sports reporter for The Dispatch.

marace@dispatch.com

bluejacketsxtra.com plus

Free access to premium content

Sign up // Learn more // Win prizes

Weekly Online Chats

Wednesdays at noon during the Blue Jacket’s season, Dispatch beat writers Aaron Portzline or Shawn Mitchell answer readers’ questions. Join us for our next Blue Jackets online chat or read the most recent chat transcript.

cannon fodder podcast

Cannon Fodder is the podcast from The Dispatch sports team covering the Blue Jackets. Tune in for lively discussions about the team and the rest of the NHL. Subscribe to the show through its RSS feed or iTunes.